Have questions about your restaurant tech? Get a free expert consultation.

Talk to a Restaurant Tech Expert →

Vaidhy Murti on Restaurant Gamification — Full Transcript | RTG Ep. 365

This is the complete transcript of RTG Ep. 365 with Vaidhy Murti, Founder and CEO of WIT. For the show notes, the key numbers and the players, see the episode page: Why QSR Gamification Beats the Mailer — Vaidhy Murti, WIT.

What this conversation covers

Vaidhy Murti started WIT in May 2018 as a consumer video contest app, pivoted once into a branded influencer agency, and by August 2020 was nearly out of money. The NBA restarting in the bubble with no fans in the stands gave him one last idea: white-label the contest engine and sell gamification to sports teams. Five years later WIT runs 40 turnkey digital experiences across the major North American leagues, and has turned that machinery toward quick service restaurants.

The argument he makes to operators is narrow and financial. The best loyalty platforms in QSR capture 20 to 30 percent of total volume and most capture 10 to 15 percent, which leaves roughly 70 percent of transactions anonymous — and at the single-franchisee level, where corporate owns the loyalty data, effectively all of it. Meanwhile operators keep spending local marketing budget on printed mailers that redeem at 1 to 2 percent and leave no list behind. Murti says swapping the mailer for a digital game pulls three to five times the redemptions on the same money, and he walks through the mechanics: 7 Brew’s month-long Brew Madness scratch-and-win with a Ford Bronco grand prize, a Ziggi’s Coffee slot machine that he says lifted sales 15 percent against a normal Tuesday, progressive profiling that asks one new question per play, and an expected-revenue-per-code model that caps the margin exposure before any prize goes out. He also makes the case that none of this replaces a loyalty program — it feeds one.

Jump to a section:

How a Hail Mary Pivot Put WIT in the NBA Bubble (0:01)

Jeremy Julian: Welcome back to the Restaurant Technology Guys podcast. I thank everyone out there for joining us. As I say each and every time, I know you guys have got lots of choices. So thank you for hanging out. Today is a topic that I’ve been wondering and I guess not even wondering, trying to figure out how to explore. And so I’m super excited that we’ve got our guest on today because I continue to see more and more proliferation of what the team at at WIT has been doing. But Vaidhy, why don’t you give us a little bit of background? You know, who are you? Where did you come from? You’ve been doing this for more than a week or two. You know, you you’ve been an expert in this space for quite some time. So why don’t you give me a little bit of your background, kind of where you came from? W if you really want to get into the Jersey roots, you and I can chat Jersey. Longtime listeners know that I love talking about Jersey when I get a chance. But but where where did you come from before we kind of jump straight into to what WIT’s been building?

Vaidhy Murti: Well, first of all, thanks so much for having me on the show, Jeremy. I really, really appreciate it. I’m excited to dive into gamification today. And yeah, we we definitely have a couple of weeks, more than a couple of weeks doing this, and we’ve probably lost track over time, but every single week is an exciting one and we look forward to it. I I grew up most of my life in Central Jersey, so very excited to hear that you grew up locally in the in the town next over, and I don’t know often meet Jersey folks serendipitously on calls like this, and so definitely have to trade some wrecks, but spent most of my life here. went to college. When I was in college, I started a company that initially the goal was to connect college students in a pre-swipe-based dating app era world and spent five years building that business, lots of high highs, lots of difficult times, lots of learnings, and translated that over starting this company back in May of 2018. So We’re talking almost 10 years now. I’m like dating myself, but the initial goal was to build a fun, exciting social consumer app. we wanted to build a video contest app and it started off that way. It was like an HQ Trivia meets Vine style entertainment platform. Ran it for about a year, pivoted one time, ran the pivot, which was kind of a branded influencer agency for another year. And we were kind of met with a difficult decision in August of 2020, trying to figure out. What to do with the business. And I’m a huge sports fan. And the NBA came back to the bubble. You had fans going like this on the sides of the court. I’d never seen any kind of sporting event without fans in the stands before. And we thought maybe one last shot, one last Hail Mary, we could try to white label the core video contest platform we had built and turned it into gamification for sports teams. And it wasn’t an overnight like success story by any means, but but five years later, we became the leading gamification platform across sports in North America, providing 40 different turnkey digital experiences designed to engage fans, capture more first party data, personalize kind of the direct communications. and it’s been a wild, wide ride. It’s been for me especially growing up here in in New Jersey, getting to work with some of our local teams has been probably the most exciting part of that. I don’t know Gotta ask you, Jeremy, who who are your local affiliations?

Jeremy Julian: So I’m a Yankees fan. don’t don’t hate me for that. I I did I’m a huge Yankees fan. I was I was back there last summer for for old timers day, actually. got got to go catch a Yankees game and as we’re recording this, we’re starting the twenty twenty six playoffs. Yankees Red Sox first round of the playoffs this evening. So yes, I’m a Yankees fan. I did grow up in Southern California during the during the Lakers era, so I happen to be a Lakers fan on the NBA side, although my father was very excited that the Knicks won this past season.

Vaidhy Murti: Okay. I definitely don’t hate you. I I’m I’m hopefully we have a a good run.

Jeremy Julian: ‘Cause he grew up as a Knicks fan. and I’m not a really a huge huge football fan, but but yeah, I I I did follow the follow the Giants more so than the Jets back in the day there. So how about you?

Vaidhy Murti: That’s always an interesting one, right? Like when I when I meet somebody from Jersey, especially Central Jersey, it’s like, are you Giants? Are you Jets? Are you Eagles? Like, which way does it fall? I I grew up a big Giants fan, I’m a Yankees fan as well. Interestingly enough, like big basketball fan, but I was a New Jersey Nets fan growing up. The Lakers were the first team I ever really watched when the Lakers were playing the Nets in like the early 2000s. And I don’t know. It was very inspiring to me. I want to be a professional basketball player. Starting point guard in the NBA until I was 13. And then I realized that that dream is probably never gonna materialize. But we do work very closely with the Giants. And as an example of kind of the work we do with them, they had a hundredth anniversary a couple of years ago. big season, big celebration. They were looking to do all sorts of different types of digital experiences, gamification, ways to engage fans, past, present, future, celebrating the history of the organization. We ran like a really cool hundredth anniversary bracket challenge with them where you could vote on your favorite Giants play of all time. They started with a bracket of 64 plays and it whittled down to the Helmet Catch that ended up winning us that that Super Bowl, which is really exciting. but essentially, yeah, definitely one of the best moments for o of my life growing up, watching those two Super Bowls and you know, just getting to be here for the magic of it.

Jeremy Julian: That’s awesome. That was that was a pretty fantastic play.

Vaidhy Murti: but a as a business, we we grew quickly in sports and we noticed that what we had built ha was broadly applicable outside of it. And over the course of the last couple of years, we’ve been expanding, bas basically been trying to take that magic that we’ve captured of game day and and bring it to other brands and other categories. And so QSR has been a really, really great, you know, journey for us, adventure for us. I’m a longtime consumer of all the different food, all the different beverages. And it’s been really, really exciting to apply the learnings that have made us successful in sports into an industry that is looking to identify their customers better, looking to drive sales, drive incremental visits, increase personalization in a macroeconomic environment that’s been challenging for any number of reasons. So excited to dive into any of that, but it’s it’s always great to connect with another New Jersey fan.

What Gamification Means When It Is Done Right (6:17)

Jeremy Julian: I love it. well, and so for for our listeners out there, I guess there’s a lot of people that I guess are the on the receiving end of gamification. But I find that at least knowing the technical background of some of these things, they don’t understand that they’re that they’re not even that that they’re being groomed to understand and drive behavior. I guess I’d love for you to share a little bit of that, and not in a manipulative way, but like in a hey, we’re gonna add value to you way. And so a lot of people I think villainize. the whole idea of gamification, but I’d love for you to talk a little bit about what is gamification at at its highest level, define it for our listeners, because I think it’s gonna lead into how and why it’s working in the brands that you guys are are doing so well in.

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah, absolutely, Jeremy. It’s it’s a very broad, you know, I’d say broad theme, like it can mean any number of things. For us, gamification is typically running some sort of exciting digital game like a scratch and win or a prize wheel or a trivia or in sports a predictive Pick’em or a bracket challenge or a personality quiz. just a mini digital experience that usually has some component of you providing your name and your email address. But the most important part of that is value exchange, right? So you get something in return for that. And I think that’s what we do well, that makes it feel less like you’re kind of just filling out your data to give it to a company or a brand, but you’re actually getting something in return. And typically, if you’re a fan of a brand or a fan of a sports team that’s running something out, we try to make it as compelling as possible. We try to make it exciting. I think like taking a step back from it all, some of the most at least for me growing up, like some of the most exciting memories of my life were sporting events. And that might be just because I was a huge sports fan, but like the magical feeling of my team, the Giants, like winning the Super Bowl when they were definitely not supposed to win either of those Super Bowls, right? Or big tennis fan, like Roger Federer or winning. Even I I’ll I’ll go I’ll go, you know, more recent, like back, you know, winning the Australian Open in in 2017 after so many years had passed and Everybody wrote him off and said this guy’s never gonna win another major. I watched that and I was like, wow, like like if you dig deep and if you’re determined and you can just like you stay at it for long enough, like magic can happen. we try to bring that magic and we try to deliver that magic to the end users and end consumers of all of our partners, right? So for our sporting teams, a lot of the times we’re giving away like really exciting experiences, two courtside tickets to a game or You know, the opportunity to win kind of autograph memorabilia or an autograph jersey or a meet and greet with your favorite player, or sometimes we give away suite nights, right? So I think it starts with how are we trying to provide rewards? How are we trying to provide exciting value and give fans the opportunity to potentially win something that might be once in a lifetime on the QSR side? We run like a really exciting campaign with 7 Brew every year, which I’m sure they’re popping up all over. They’re they’re probably already concentrated at the market near you. the the

Jeremy Julian: one hundred percent. And my hi my son’s girlfriend is like she’ll drive twenty minutes to get to one. Now there’s one closer. But yeah, no, 7 Brew been on a on a tear recently. And I do wanna dig into kind of what you guys have been doing for them ’cause I’m I’m excited to share that story, but I’ll let you keep going.

Vaidhy Murti: That’s awesome. Will she also wait in line for two to three hours to get a a promotional item?

Jeremy Julian: So now she’s working. So they just moved off to college. Her her and my son went off to college in Abilene. And so she got a job at 7 Brew. But they had a promotional item recently, and she’s like, I’m not waiting in that line. I’m just gonna, I’m I’m gonna go to work and just go go get it in the background. But in general, she used to do that same thing. But you talk about these once-in-a-lifetime experiences or these these purpose driven reasons to engage with a brand is kind of where I like to I I guess I like to to have you talk about it. Is your creating incidents that aren’t just a discount, that aren’t just a, hey, buy two, get one free type of things, which is kind of the traditional marketing playbook. It’s something different. It’s something unique. It’s something engaging. I guess you know, that’s kind of what I want to want our listeners to hear. Is that fair?

7 Brew’s Brew Madness and the Ford Bronco Giveaway (10:31)

Vaidhy Murti: Absolutely. And so with that 7 Brew example, they ran a really exciting national campaign with us last year. It was called Flavor Madness. Then they ran it back this year called Brew Madness. Throughout the month of March, trying to capitalize on the hype around March Madness, they were giving away a whole host of exciting prizes. And so you could go to any of their stands. you could enter kind of the digital scratch and win game directly in the drive-thru. And so you place your order, you’re waiting for three to four minutes to actually go pick up your drinks. And you have a lot of time on your hands, right? So it’s a way to surprise and delight all your customers while they’re in that line with all sorts of exciting things. So some of the prizes were free drinks, 7 Brew branded basketball, 7 Brew branded Pop-A-Shot, jerseys, things like that. But then the grand prize was a Ford Bronco last year. And so yeah, it it was incredible. And the the the way the mechanics behind it that were so successful were such that you could enter every single day for the month of March. You can come in, you can play every day. Every time you played, you were entered for a chance to win that Ford Bronco. And the customer who ended up winning that Bronco last year was a 7 Brew superfan, who’s actually like a special needs teacher. And it was like a beautiful story. They like gave her the Bronco, she was super excited. They like made this like whole like really nice video about it. And I think it it’s like Core to the brand values as well, right? They’re giving away something that’s values aligned. Like it’s an amazing prize. Everybody, I think, who saw that video watched it. And I mean, it was it was a heartfelt thing to watch. And I think that’s what it’s all about. Like, can you create exciting, magical customer moments that actually resonate with your brand? And can it be authentic? And gamification is just the vehicle to allow that experience to happen, right? We’re just trying to take What was previously a less valuable exchange where you know somebody gives you a boring sweepstakes form and they’re like, give me your data. Or, you know, a more rudimentary way of doing it that we see a lot in in restaurants is there’ll be like a my my local coffee shop here at Bell Works, which is the newly formed co-working space that used to be like the Bell Labs building that my mom used to work at. And now they film Severance at my local coffee shop, they have a paper. That you can walk into, write down your email address, and you’re entered into a pool where they will manually draw an email and they’ll give you free coffee for the next month every Monday to like some random person. And I always go in and I see there’s like three names on that, or maybe like four names on that sheet. We just take that, we make it exciting, we make it beautiful, and then we add the element of instant gratification to it, right? So instead of you just like, giving somebody your email address is there the opportunity for you to win something back or earn something back and just improve that value exchange. So you’re more likely to do it. and we’ve we’ve found a lot of success with that.

Why McDonald’s Monopoly Has Outlived Every Other Promotion (13:32)

Jeremy Julian: Yeah. So I’ve got a couple of thoughts in in my mind. The first is I I’m I think everybody listening has probably gone through the McDonald’s, you know, Monopoly scratchers game where you’d pull off the the monopoly, you know, packs. That is, I mean, old school gamification well before the digital world. I guess I’d love why was that such a successful campaign that they kept coming back to it? You know, I guess just from an education piece. And then let’s talk about how you guys are digitizing that and then creating that at mass, not just kind of. Hey, I gotta go in and I gotta get the large fry because then I get the scratcher and not the medium fry ’cause it didn’t have the you know, the pull tab or whatever.

Vaidhy Murti: Absolutely, that must be one of the best examples in QSR that exists. And they’re actually bringing that back next week. And so the fact that they ke

Jeremy Julian: That’s funny that I I I had no I’m not a huge McDonald’s person, but that’s funny. But it it makes me think about they’ve been doing it for years. Maybe some of it’s to get data, some of it’s a sales uplift, some of, you know, lots of different reasons why they did it. But why has that been such such a successful campaign? Because it feels like it’s gone on forever, has it not?

Why Operators Know Almost Nothing About Their Own Guests (14:31)

Vaidhy Murti: I think so. And they run it back. They’ve they’ve run it every couple of years now. It’s been really successful. And when they’re doing it, when like the leading one of the leading QSR brands is doing it, they must have data to prove that it actually works. But I think at like a primal level, we as humans are just hardwired to engage in and love games. Like we like playing games. We like the idea of like winning reward. We like collecting. Like going back to the 7 Brew like scenario of them doing like these collectibles where You’ll have customers waiting in line for three hours to get, you know, a collectible that’s like not worth that much money, but the fact that there’s scarcity around it immediately makes it interesting and exciting. And after that story you just told, we might have a bunch of people go apply to work at 7 Brew as a as a way to short circuit that line now. but I think people love like the chase. They love playing games, they love like doing something with the opportunity to get a reward at the end of that. And I think for a lot of them. They’re already in the back of their minds thinking about, when am I going to go get my next Big Mac? And all you’re doing is providing a more exciting incentive around it. Like we appreciate you as a customer. We’re going to find a way to give back to you in some way by running this game that gives you a chance to win a million dollars. And I know there’s a storied history of this game as well over the years, but I think that is has been one of the I mean that that’s inspired us as well. In the QSR space, like finding ways to create exciting moments. I think whether you’re capturing drive-through traffic or whether I think a more common example is we have all these operators who don’t have any idea who their customers are. Like they corporate oftentimes owns not even oftentimes, I think almost always corporate owns the loyalty platform. So whatever the rewards platform or the loyalty platform is. It’s something that corporate owns and manages, and they kind of have the email addresses and the phone numbers. But even the best loyalty platforms that exist in QSR only capture 20 to 30% of total volume. So you have like 70% of transactions are already untracked or fully anonymous. And you take it down to the operator level, 100% are completely anonymous. Like they have no idea. And I think personal example, I was born into a Dunkin’ family. So like I grew up, my mom was like, A huge Dunkin’ fan, Dunkin’ lifer. And I’ve been going to three Dunkin’ locations, like triangulated across where I grew up and where I live now for the last 25 years. But none of them know who I am. Not a single one of them. And they don’t know who I am. They don’t know that I always order I’m a creature of habit. I will like almost always order an egg and cheese on an English muffin with white cheddar instead of American. I’ll get a side of hash rounds, I’ll get a wake-up wrap also with white cheddar, and then I’ll get like a iced coffee, usually black. Nobody knows that about me. My wife, a few weeks ago, or maybe it was probably few months ago, when they launched the peanut butter Dunkalatte, she loves peanut butter, and for a period of time she was getting peanut butter Dunkalattes like every other day, but nobody knows that. Nobody has that information, right? And so what we try to do is build these exciting digital experiences that encourage people like me or my wife to participate in a game where we might provide some of that information. We might provide a little bit of those insights directly to the operator and to corporate in exchange for something. Maybe I’m getting a BOGO or a 20% off, or maybe I’m just like filling out one challenge in a multi-challenge scavenger hunt. To be entered to win a Dunkin’ swag bag, which is a real thing we’re doing with a Dunkin’ operator right now. And I think the other part more broadly that we try to help operators with is the national calendar, the national marketing calendar is good. Everyone pays into that fund, but it’s not personal, right? So it’s not, it’s very generic. Like I’m like I’ve seen Dunkin’ do a great job of like the Kylie drinks, like Alex Earle drinks, but like. I drink black coffee and like that’s like probably all I’m gonna drink for for a long time. So it’s like it’s not personalized to me. And so we attempt to essentially take the same personalization that we brought to the sports world and we try to bring that to QSR. I think like today is National Coffee Day, and the only reason I know that is because we work with multiple Dunkin’ operators running, yeah, that’s the only reason. Like, no, there’s no other touch point that like made me aware of that.

Jeremy Julian: Yeah, ’cause you’re in that world. You’re in that marketing world, right?

Vaidhy Murti: and we try to kind of put that power back in the hands of operators to allow them to build their own audiences so that they can drive those customers back for additional visits. Ultimately, the goal is always drive sales.

Driving a Third Visit When You Are Not a Coffee Brand (19:24)

Jeremy Julian: Yep. So I’m gonna challenge you real quick, Vaidhy, about so coffee is a is a high frequency engagement. So it’s it people always use coffee as a, it’s really easy. You get your coffee every week or every day, or you know, every time you go to the office. I’m in the office Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. I get coffee Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. Talk to me about those less frequent engagements, other QSRs. I know you guys work with Taco Bell. I was just at FS Tech last week here in Dallas, food service technology show. Was listening to Ziggi’s Coffee and he the CMO was on stage and he was talking about marketing to the third visit. And again, that was a coffee brand and he he admitted it. He’s like, Yeah, it’s easier for me because people drink coffee every day, you know, to figure out how to get them to the third visit. A lot of times people in the gamification world, let me give you a BOGO. McDonald’s did it famously. download the app and you’ll get a free whatever. You know, Chick-fil-A did the same thing, and then nobody ever comes back. So marketing to that third visit, how does gamification play into that? Getting here on a third visit when it’s not an everyday occurrence, stop by Dunkin’ or stop by, you know, Scooter’s Coffee or whatever that might look like.

Vaidhy Murti: That’s a great question. speaking of Ziggi’s, I love that you brought that up. So they actually ran a campaign with us for St. Patrick’s Day this year. And so they ran like a lucky slot machine. The way this worked, the mechanics behind it were that they sent out the game via email to their entire email database. So you could play the game immediately, and then you could come in and redeem that day itself. And so they were trying to drive same-day redemptions. I think like overall. Sales were up fifteen percent compared to like a random Tuesday. So it was like a very clear

Jeremy Julian: He admitted that on stage. So that’s funny that you say that. We took we specifically talked about your contest. He didn’t use your guys’ brand name in that conversation, but I asked a question about how does he gamify and then how does he communicate out to the front lines that they’ve sent this offer? Because that’s the other problem is if the associates in the store don’t know that this is coming, it creates a bad guest experience. So sorry, I’ll let you can kind of finish on that thought. But he did specifically, it was just last week here, you know, 20 minutes from the house. I sat in his session. talking, you know, listening to how are people gamifying this and how are they getting the desired results? And he talked specifically about the uplift that you guys were able to create for him.

Vaidhy Murti: I love that. that’s that’s great. I gotta I’m probably gonna ping him after this and and and tell him thank you. But essentially I think coffee is is like like you said, Jeremy, very habit driven, right? People go get their coffee every day. for a lot of people it’s just like part of the the daily routine. I think for some of the other types of brands, like the Taco Bells, like you mentioned, or we work we work with Mike’s as well. Mike’s Red Tacos, which LeBron just invested in a couple of weeks ago, which is exciting. Or like the Pizza Huts of the World, the Zaxby’s, the Little Caesars, like when you’re looking to to drive that additional visit, like the way we think about it is can we create some sort of exciting experience, whether it’s in the store, in the drive-thru, even third party delivery? If you’re deliver if you’re ordering through third party delivery and you know the the group has no idea who you are because Uber or DoorDash is kind of keeping your information, can you put like a bag tag on there with a QR code? Where the customer gets their food, plays, and now you know who they are. So like you can kind of directly communicate with them. But but step one is building up that database of customers that are already coming to kind of visit you or already coming in for their orders. Step two is we try to progressively profile those customers over a period of time. So if you go in and you play a game at Dunkin’, and then next week you play another game, and then next week you play another game, every time you play, we will ask you a new question. That will provide some sort of valuable insight back to the Dunkin’ franchisee about like what your kind of behavior is, right? So one of the questions might be like, when do you typically come to Dunkin’? Is it breakfast? Is it lunch? Is it after lunch? Is it dinner? And like that’ll help them target the day part. Like, when are you are you a lunch customer? Are you breakfast customer? Do we want to try to bring you in to for a trial and like another day part if we’re looking to drive traffic? a question might be what are your favorite types of offers? Like, do you like free coffee? Do you like free donuts? Do you like free muffins? Right. And all that will kind of give you a better, you know, idea around that customer. The next question might be how frequently do you visit Dunkin’? Are you daily? Are you, you know, once or twice a week? Are you once or twice a month? Are you infrequent? And that allows us through our platform then to segment and filter on the customers who have only come back maybe one time in the last two months or Two times in the last two months, and we’re looking to drive that third visit. Well, instead of giving everybody a blanket offer that they can all, you know, get a free BOGO that might hurt the margin, we can be a little bit more sophisticated in the different types of offers we provide, the different types of customers where for the customers that are already daily, we’re not looking to cannibalize an existing check. But for the customers who haven’t been back in a while, we can understand what are the types of offers that will Galvanize action, right? What are the types of offers that if we send this person this type of offer that’s a little bit more personal, it’ll actually get them to kind of take action, come back in for that third visit. And I think outside of coffee, the average ticket is a lot bigger, right? So while it might not be as frequent as kind of coming in for your daily coffee, the ability to drive those additional visits in a repeatable manner will significantly increase year-round sales. And that’s The entire goal of the platform ultimately. It’s like invest in building up your own audience and then very effectively segment that audience, provide them with personalized value at scale, and let that value build deeper relationships that ends up driving your top line.

Jeremy Julian: Yeah, no, and I and the thing that you said earlier that I think all too often people that are in this world don’t think about is you’re offering value up front. It’s not just a, you know, it’s you’re you’re getting them engaged in some engagement with the brand to give you data in a way that doesn’t look like a a form that I’m filling out at the DMV to fill out my loyalty profile. And so that that’s probably the biggest thing that I love that you guys do. one real quick thought before I jump into kind of the mechanics of how it works and where it layers and and all of those kind of things. Is talk to me a little bit about experiences and I’ll I’ll give you a quick real life story. We’ve been partnered with the Cheesecake Factory and and the core business for quite some time. We go to their charity event every year, and the biggest prize at the end of the charity event, you know, in the live auction is bidding for dinner with the executive chef and the founder of the brand. It’s an experience. It’s not something that you can buy. You can’t just go hang out with the guy that founded the Cheesecake Factory and is executive chef. At his home in Malibu and have dinner. So it becomes this experiential thing. You talked about, you know, again, Dr Pepper, you know, college football season right now. They do the kick, you know, kicking the field goals. And, you know, a lot of people are doing these experiential things that are are different, not necessarily the same monetary value. It has a different value. You talked about sports teams, you know, getting to walk locker room or getting to hang out and spend some time, you know, getting things that you can’t just go buy. I guess talk to me a little bit about the difference between Hey, I’m gonna get your free cup of coffee and your fifth visit versus, you know, some experience where I get to go walk walk the roastery, you know, for for Ziggi’s or or something along those lines.

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah, I mean, first of all, that’s awesome. And I love the Cheesecake Factory, though we’ve probably been in the same once. The Cheesecake Factory in Freehold was like where I would go a lot growing up. And the first time I opened that menu and like saw all the different cheesecakes I could get, I looked at my mom and I was like, How is this real?

Jeremy Julian: Yes. Yeah. It’s their their their test kitchen in Calabasas is remarkable. I did actually a college paper on business on them back in college, before we were doing business with them, because I it they really are remarkable. Everything is made in-house, fresh every day. All of the sauces are made, nothing comes in on a cart. They cut the tomatoes in the store. They I mean, every single sauce that you get is made in store that, you know, that week. So sorry, I’ll let you keep going. But yes, they they’re pretty remarkable in that way. But The thing that’s so cool about it is they offer access to that. And it’s more valuable than buying even a trip to Cabo, you know, an all expense paid trip to Cabo, you know, or whatever else that that somebody might have donated their vacation home, you know, as part of their charity charity tournament or whatever.

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah, absolutely. Like, first of all, I think it’s super cool that it’s all done in-house. I I have so many fond memories of going there as a kid and just like, which cheesecake do I try? Like, there’s so many. they all look so good. But I think like what you’re what you’re hitting on, Jeremy, is just that. Like, I think as we move more and more into this experience first economy, where especially I think the younger generations are really, really putting a huge emphasis on the value of these experiences. Like, goes back to the 7 Brew thing. It’s like, Do I really need like a one or two dollar collectible that has no intrinsic value, but that through people will wait three hours in line because it has so much extrinsic value because of the scarcity around it? and I think that’s what like it goes back to like the gnomes, right? at the Masters. It’s like people want experiences, they want items that cannot be bought, right? And that they’re exciting for them, that resonate with them, resonate with the brand. and so Gi like giveaways can can definitely provide that. I think we probably can’t give once-in-a-lifetime experiences to every single person who participates, but a lot of the time if that’s a halo prize, like you’re entering in for the chance to win something that is truly unique or truly life-changing, it’s a great best practice because it’s going to encourage many, many people to participate. even if they walk away with a BOGO or they walk away with a free medium drink or 20% off their next order, like they are getting something in return for participating. And you know, there’s that chance that they can go in and still win like that ultimate experience that money can’t buy that is really, really unique. And so we love whenever we see any of our partners give these types of things away. I know the Cavs have done this before where like they’ve auctioned off a trip on the plane with the players, which reminds me of what you’re talking about. And we we’ve had the Islanders recently, this is a little bit different, but they actually sourced fan designs for their third jersey this year. And then they actually are making the jersey based on a fan submitted design, which again is like giving the fans like an outsized say in what should we do next, right? Which deepens that relationship. And as it relates to QSR, it’s you know, what flavor should we launch next? Or like what item or what combo would you be super excited about? Putting some of that agency and some of that excitement in the hands of your most loyal customers, giving them a say, I think is a really, really powerful thing to do. And it it helps to reaffirm that this is a two sided relationship where, you know, the fans have a voice, the loyal customers have a voice, and we’re all in this together.

Why Experiences Beat Discounts in Restaurant Loyalty (30:41)

Jeremy Julian: Yeah, no, I and and I love the the idea of being unique and having different it’s not just your standard loyalty program that just you get you know buy five five dozen donuts and you get your six one free. Like those are cool, but they don’t necessarily drive the behavior. And my son, who’s dating the 7 Brew girl, is a huge Pokemon guy. And so he they’ve done gamification better than anything. I mean, I actually study what they do because I’m like, he that freaking kid’s gonna go Line up at the darn. I he’s 21 years old and he lines up at the stupid machine to see what the drop is this week to get the Pokemon cards. And I’m like, I don’t get it. But obviously they’ve gotten him to a place that now he wants to brag to his friends that he got this card that, you know, that’s out there. And I think this is the idea that that human behavior has been this way forever. Now it’s a question of how do we help it to drive business value, to drive incidents, to drive fandom, you know, because to that lady that won. The Bronco, I promise you, is going to drink 7 Brew for the rest of her her life. She is going to be a superfan of that brand and and and be there. tactically, we’ve had a lot of people that have come on that have talked about one-to-one marketing, that have that that have the email list, that have a loyalty program. I already do this with my loyalty program. Why is WIT different? I I I know that, but I’d love for you to kind of talk a little bit about it’s not just your standard loyalty package. My understanding, at least, is that you guys can sit on top, you can sit alongside. You can do lots of different things, you know, to kind of help engage. So I guess why is it not just kind of the standard loyalty package that’s out there in the world today?

How Gamification Sits on Top of Loyalty Instead of Replacing It (32:12)

Vaidhy Murti: That’s a great question. So we augment loyalty and we complement loyalty and we directly integrate with loyalty. So we’re definitely goal is never for us to replace the loyalty program or platform. It’s just to make it more exciting. Now, at like the highest level, like I mentioned at the top of the call, I think 20 the best loyalty platforms acquire 20 to 30 percent of a brand’s overall customers, like the very, very best. And I think Most are probably in that 10 to 15% range. And so step one of what we do is help with that point of sale acquisition, right? How do we actually acquire that customer and turn that anonymous guest into an identifiable visitor that you can get them to opt into your loyalty platform? Right. What we found with our Dunkin’ operators, for example, is when you opt into Dunkin’ Rewards, the lifetime value of that customer goes up. Like 70% simply by by making kind of that opt-in. And I think that’s why corporate always invests so heavily in let’s push out the loyalty platform. But if we don’t have enough people in the loyalty platform, right, like that’s kind of untapped value number one. And that’s a lot of what we focus on. A really good example is a lot of our franchise partners have done physical mailers for a really long time. They do you know, they’ll send out 10,000 mailers to wherever they’re opening or wherever they’re looking to drive sales at. There’ll be coupons in there that come in the mail. You can go in and you can scan your coupon to get some kind of discount. And the whole hope is it drives some number of redemptions. And so a good example with a Dunkin’ group that we work with, relatively large group, they will typically send out a mailer in one of their markets of 10 to 20,000 households and they’ll see a 1% redemption rate on that, meaning that. If it reaches 10,000 households, like there will be a hundred redemptions of those coupons over the course of you know the run of the mailer. And QSR industry standard is like one to two percent redemption rate on a mailer. the best we’ve seen is like three to four percent. Usually doesn’t get much better than that unless the offers are insane. But the point is, like, even if I go in, I just got one because there’s a new Smoothie King like across the street. Even if I go in and I use the Smoothie King coupon that I got, Smoothie King has no idea who I am. The operator doesn’t know me. They don’t have my email address. There’s no way to contact me. If there’s a new opening, we’re doing this with Swig right now, where they historically would have done mailers to announce in a new market that Swig is coming to town. But instead, they’re running a slot machine campaign where I give my email address, I play the game, and I can win very similar or the exact same prizes. Digitally that I can use as soon as that Swig opens. And now not only have they built an owned audience of the people who are going to come in and redeem, but they can remarket to me and they can bring me back again and again and again. And so we can now, like with that same Dunkin’ group that I mentioned, by us sending a simple email with an exciting game. We we actually did that today for National Coffee Day, we can drive like Three times as many redemptions with like a relatively small, you know, almost 10,000 member database compared to if we if they were to send out a mailer. And it it’s much more efficient because the marginal cost is zero. And so we’re doing all of that for the operator. At the same time, we are trying to convert all of those people into Dunkin’ Rewards members because that’ll increase their lifetime value for the brand. And so one of the progressive profiling questions. That will ask in order is are you a rewards member? And if they say no, now we know that we have a great opportunity to try to convert them. I’ll take like one more shot at this from the other side. So corporate, when they run nationwide activations with us, a lot of the times when we’re launching one of these, you put in your email address, you put in your phone number, whatever loyalty is tied to. As soon as you play the game, there’s a checkbox that allows you to opt directly into the loyalty platform. And we can just directly integrate, right? So with 7 Brew, you want to play the Scratch and Win game. It’s tied loyalty for them is tied to phone number. And so once you play the game and you check off the box, it’ll dynamically create a 7 Brew loyalty account for you. And so they’re using the gamification as a top-of-funnel way to encourage the downstream actions they’re looking for, which is get people into the loyalty platform. And then when they’re in loyalty, you can run super exclusive drops and like custom activations for only those most loyal members, right? So we kind just make the experience better and better and better. And then maybe we can make it more scarce and more exciting for the customers who are displaying the behaviors that we want to to incentivize the most.

Keeping a Campaign Personal Without Building Hundreds of Offers (37:03)

Jeremy Julian: So last line of questioning before we jump into kind of how people get engaged and and do this, how do we make it not just the same same? Where 7 Brew and Dunkin’ and everybody, like how customized can you get? We’re 37 minutes into recording. We haven’t talked about AI and how we can get, you know, specifics. You guys have been around well before AI even was a thing. For those of us that have been in the tech world, we’ve had the same type of technology as AI. It’s just now the rest of the world is seeing this stuff. But how do you get the how do you get it to be? This customized so it feels like 7 Brew. It has the brand ethos. The offers are 7 Brew esque. I’m not a 7 Brew drinker. I don’t drink that. I don’t drink coffee either. So it’s like none of it makes any sense to me. So activating me is going be really, really challenging because it’s not my jam. Give me a whole bunch of other brands and I can tell you exactly what’s going to make me move the needle. How do you make it so that it’s not just so generic, but you get what you’re looking for so that it feels like an offer specific to me without killing yourself? and having hundreds of thousands of offers, you know, type of thing. I guess I’d love for you to talk a little bit about that because I can see brands going, that’s great for Dunkin’. They have a huge marketing budget. Their whole marketing department’s bigger than my whole company. Whatever, you know, something along those lines. So I’d love for you to kind of kind of share a little bit about how you guys get it down to a place that it really is effective for the brands that need it.

Expected Revenue Per Code, and How to Cap the Margin Hit (38:22)

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah, absolutely. It’s it’s a really good question and it’s a it’s a delicate balance, right? We don’t want to ever cannibalize existing orders, right? So one of the strategies around that is a lot of the times with 7 Brew, if we’re running something and you win a prize, you’re gonna get that prize delivered to you in 24 hours to be used on your next visit, right? So we’re never trying to take away sales from an existing ticket that you’re already I think a big so to answer the last part of that question, Dunkin’s massive marketing budget, most of the work that we do is actually with the operators. It’s with the multi-unit operators who already have an LSM budget that they’re allocating. And we just do it more efficiently, right? So if they’re spending $5,000 on a mailer, they can spend the exact same thing with us and they will get three to five times more conversion. Or in the case of a local 7 Brew operator group, we we did local to you, they they ran something with us that did 10 times better than. Mailer that they had run out recently, right? From a redemption rate perspective. So it is just reallocating existing budget in a more effective digital first age. Now, the question of how do you do this and make it personalized is a really good one. So our platform allows an incredibly deep level of customization. And so when Dunkin’ launches a campaign with us or a Dunkin’ group launches a campaign with us, everything is customized, like the branding, the logos, like We can get very, very deep. So for March Madness, for example, like we had a custom seasonal Munchkin. We had a game where you could shoot a custom seasonal Munchkin into a Dunkin’ branded basketball hoop, right? Around March Madness. And like that’s like 7 Brew’s not doing that exact same thing. But actually, we ran something in Missouri with a 7 Brew group where we around March Madness, where you were shooting like a Mizzou branded ball into a 7 Brew basketball hoop, right? So it’s like The core mechanics of the platform are proven, but our ability to personalize very quickly at scale is like what sets us apart. And so you can set up activations on our platform, and we really we do the heavy lifting in less than 10 minutes. It doesn’t take days, it doesn’t take weeks. And once a brand is set up on the platform, it allows you to be super proactive, but also super reactive and just capitalize on the moment. Very last piece of it. So you talked about how do you prevent giving away, you know, 100,000 discounts, right? And like totally eating the margin. We look at the downstream conversion of every single prize type and we get better for every new game that we launch, right? So with a local 7 Brew group that we just ran a couple of exciting promotions with, Corporate had actually given them data that like they they have like a two for nine promotion that a lot of the 7 Brew Customers that have have had and you know they they push it a lot because it’s like a very effective promotion for them. We’re able to actually track what is the redemption rate of that versus a free medium beverage or a BOGO. And then we’re also able to combine that with their POS data and look at the attachment rate of every single prize, right? So I might be giving somebody a free drink, but like what percentage of those people come in and only get the free drink? Or, you know, how many of them, what is the percentage of attachment and what is the ticket size of that attachment? And based on all that data, We can actually come up with an expected revenue per code awarded, which helps inform how do you protect the bottom line, right? And that informs the distribution of prizes. And so once we have all that information, we can structure prizes in a way where the hit to your margin is fully capped because we know it’s actually not even hit, because we know what the attachment rate is and what the average ticket size.

Jeremy Julian: Yeah, you know what it would’ve looked like had you not thrown the promotion out there and you now you know what the new uplift looks like and how much did you spend to get there.

The Progressive Profiling Answer That Surprised Everyone (42:03)

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah. And so we we just design it based on the data that we see and different offers resonate in different markets. And one of our Dunkin’ groups, there was a super successful nine ninety-nine for for a dozen donuts offer that like resonated incredibly well. We tried that same offer in a different market and it didn’t resonate nearly as well. But the free medium beverage was like incredibly successful in that market. And so I think as we run more and more campaigns, we get more intelligent and it just allows us to ensure that the next shot on goal is even better. It also like teaches us new things that we weren’t even thinking about. And so one of the questions that one of the progressive profile questions we ask one of our Dunkin’ groups across their customers is why Dunkin’? Like, why do you pick Dunkin’ above the 7 Brew across the street or above Starbucks or the local coffee shop? And Of all of the things that are ranked, it’s a it’s a multi-select, so they can select multiple things. Friendly staff is number three on the list. Friendly staff is actually above convenience, it’s above speed of service, it’s above selection. I never would have guessed that this is the third most important reason that people are picking Dunkin’. It’s like they’re actually forming genuine connections with the staff at the operator level. but it it was super insightful for us.

Jeremy Julian: Yeah, if you were to look at my LinkedIn post from yesterday, actually, it’s a it’s specifically about the CEO group I’m part of. And we go to Capital Grille instead of Fleming’s because we feel like a nobody in Fleming’s and Capital Grille, they treat us well every month we meet and it’s an eight hundred dollar check every month. And so you know what? I promise you Fleming’s would love to have that check, but they don’t hardly even recognize who we are. They don’t add a whole lot of value. They don’t change the behavior. And to your point, Dunkin’, and knowing who those guests are and being able to being able to engage with them, we are After all, in the hospitality industry, being hospitable is kind of a big thing that that we need to need to make sure we we take care of.

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah, yeah. And like you said, like at at a core level as humans, like we all just want to feel valued. Like that I feel like that’s what it’s that’s what life is about. Like you just you want to feel valued by, you know, the people who love you, the people around you, the people you interact with on a daily basis. And I think the groups that do a really good job of of recognizing that and creating like a you know people first experience with like a high degree of care and and hospitality, they It impacts the bottom line in a very positive way.

What an Engagement With WIT Actually Looks Like (44:33)

Jeremy Julian: Yep. And and again, the fact that you guys can do it at scale back to knowing who the guest is and those mailers, you’re you never know. So so tactically, how do people get started? Like what what does an engagement with your team look like? And how how do they learn more? You know, I guess talk us through the the process. I’m a I run a 40 40 unit, you know, franchisee of one of these brands, or I’m I’m a corporation and I’ve got a hundred stores. What what does that look like from an engagement with you guys? How do they get engaged and how how does it work?

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah, well, first of all, we absolutely love this. And this is what gets us up and out of bed every morning excited to get to work. And so the first thing we’ll do is we’ll try to understand what are the goals of the organization. So in the full 40 unit multi-unit operator example, like are you planning to open up new locations? Like, do you have new openings planned? Like, are you looking to increase same store sales? Are there specific underperforming locations? Like, are there six of your units that are not hitting the AUV target? That you’re looking to kind of make changes that to kind of get you to that AUV target. We’ll we’ll get like a good understanding of the lay of the land. And I think typically we start with a pilot, right? So like a relatively low-cost test to just demonstrate that this works and it’ll positively impact your sales. And every single time we do that, it converts to a larger engagement because people kind of see the the direct magic of that. And I think at the corporate level, it’s it’s the exact same thing. Like, what are you looking to achieve? Is it We’re looking to open as many new locations as possible. there’s some kind of new menu item we’re looking to promote. Are we trying to celebrate a tent pole like National Coffee Day? We’re trying to do something really exciting. so we really just try to get an understanding of your goals and then put a plan in place that we execute end to end to ensure that you crush those goals. And for anybody looking to do that, you could go to our website at witcontests.com/RTG. You could reach out like on our LinkedIn page. You could email us at hello@witcontests.com. I’d say anybody like the easiest place to start is anybody opening a new location or anybody running a physical mailer. We could I will guarantee that we will beat it from a conversion perspective, dollar for dollar, or your money back if you want to run a test. Like that’s how confident we are getting to this point, running so many of these that it works and it works every time. That’s not to say it’s perfect the first time, but part of the beauty is every subsequent activation we run, we learn more about what resonates with the the target customers. We learn, you know, more about the offers to use. We we learn more about what are the most effective promotional strategies. And every campaign we run after that gets better and better and better. So it’s kind of a positive feedback loop that that we’re excited about. But you know, we we definitely, you know, appreciate any conversations, anybody who’s interested in learning more. this is this is what we look for.

Jeremy Julian: Yeah. And and just as a reminder, you don’t have to rip and replace all your existing systems. It can sit alongside of those existing systems. It doesn’t have to be, you know, because that’s one of the things that I hear people, that’s great. But I don’t have time to replace all, you know, Paytronix or Punchh or Thanx whatever it is that you’ve got in there. It can sit alongside of that and augment what it is that you’re doing to be able to help drive the top line sales so that you you can have, you know, the budget and the and the space to be able to do more.

Vaidhy Murti: Yeah, a hundred percent. It integrates with all the core systems, but it also just isn’t a system that needs to be managed at all. We are the system. And so it’s more about understanding the business objectives. We handle everything end-to-end, promotional graphics, execution. It really just comes down to can we get that graphic up in your store or in your email list or in the drive-thru, right? So that customers can go scan a QR code and participate. And the rest, you know, it it all speaks for itself. It it does the The gamification carries the weight of the engagements. There’s nothing new to learn. There’s nothing new that has to be implemented technically. it’s very low lift, very fast. And I think that’s also why we’ve had success with customers. I think people don’t like downloading apps and creating accounts. And we’ve really tried to optimize to make this as seamless as possible. Like, how can we deliver value in as fast and as exciting a manner as possible and reduce like every barrier to entry and every level of friction while still making it a really valuable exchange. And so we we’re excited about it and you know we’re excited to to get back to it and and continue to try to improve every day as you say AI is is coming, it’s already here and we’re watching that you know change the the world and change all these industries in a number of ways. But we we pride ourselves on being kind of at the forefront of the innovation, the technology and We’re gonna are a as a company, we try to get better every single day. And so we’re excited for today and for tomorrow.

Jeremy Julian: I love it. and like I said at the onset, I’m excited because I just I I had I’ve seen this gamification coming from the other industries into our space. and I love that you guys are sitting on the forefront of it. And so, to our listeners, guys, if you guys haven’t already checked them out, witcontests.com/RTG, go check them out, learn a little bit more. I’m telling you, if you’re not doing it, your neighbors are likely doing it and you’re gonna be falling behind because they are getting the data so that they can improve with the next campaign that’s going out. And so, If you haven’t already subscribed to the show, please do so and thank you guys for listening and make it a great day.

More from this episode

Show notes, the attributed figures, the FAQ and the three players are all on the episode page: Why QSR Gamification Beats the Mailer — Vaidhy Murti, WIT | RTG Ep. 365. You can reach WIT at witcontests.com/RTG.

This transcript was lightly edited for readability — filler removed, speaker names normalised, and brand names corrected. The substance of what was said is unchanged.