TL;DR: Vaidhy Murti, Founder and CEO of WIT, says the best loyalty platforms in QSR capture only 20 to 30 percent of total volume, which means most of what happens in your restaurants is anonymous. At the operator level he puts it at 100 percent anonymous. WIT replaces the direct mailer with a digital game, and Murti says the swap pulls three to five times the redemptions on the same budget. One Ziggi’s Coffee campaign he cites lifted sales 15 percent against a normal Tuesday.
Who is on this episode
Guest: Vaidhy Murti, Founder and Chief Executive Officer, WIT. Host: Jeremy Julian, President and Chief Revenue Officer, CBS NorthStar. Brands and platforms named in this conversation: WIT, 7 Brew, Dunkin’, Ziggi’s Coffee, Swig, Smoothie King, Taco Bell, Pizza Hut, Zaxby’s, Little Caesars, Mike’s Red Tacos, McDonald’s, DoorDash, Uber Eats, the New York Giants, the New York Islanders and the Cleveland Cavaliers.
I have been watching gamification creep in from the edges of our industry for a couple of years now, mostly from sports, and I could not figure out how to talk about it without it sounding either gimmicky or faintly manipulative. So I went and found the guy who built the thing. Vaidhy and I are both Jersey kids and both Yankees fans, which got the conversation off to a good start, and then we spent 50 minutes on something I think a lot of operators are going to wish they had understood twelve months ago.
What is gamification in a restaurant, actually?
Gamification is a short digital game — a scratch-and-win, a prize wheel, a trivia round, a slot machine — that a guest plays in exchange for their name and email or phone number. The game is the wrapper. The point is the value exchange: the guest gets something real back instead of filling in a form, so far more of them do it.
Murti was blunt about where the idea came from. He started the company in May 2018 as a consumer video contest app, pivoted once into a branded influencer agency, and by August 2020 was out of road. Then the NBA restarted in the bubble with cardboard fans in the stands.
We thought maybe one last shot, one last Hail Mary, we could try to white label the core video contest platform we had built and turn it into gamification for sports teams.
Vaidhy Murti, Founder and CEO, WIT
Five years on he describes WIT as the leading gamification platform across sports in North America, running 40 turnkey digital experiences for teams across the major leagues. QSR is where that machinery got pointed next.
How much of your guest traffic is actually anonymous?
More than you think. Murti says the very best loyalty platforms in QSR capture 20 to 30 percent of a brand’s total volume, and that most sit between 10 and 15 percent. That leaves around 70 percent of transactions untracked. And at the franchisee level, where corporate owns the loyalty platform and the email list, he puts it at 100 percent.
I have been going to three Dunkin’ locations, triangulated across where I grew up and where I live now, for the last 25 years. But none of them know who I am. Not a single one of them.
Vaidhy Murti, Founder and CEO, WIT
That is the gap. The operator is paying into a national marketing fund that buys a generic calendar, and has no list of their own to work. It is the same structural problem Yosef Peterseil described from the loyalty side in Why Your Loyalty Emails Don’t Convert — Yosef Peterseil, Blings, approached from the opposite end.
Does a digital game really beat a direct mailer?
On the numbers Murti gave me, yes, and not narrowly. He says a Dunkin’ group they work with mails 10,000 to 20,000 households and sees a 1 percent redemption rate. He puts the QSR industry standard at 1 to 2 percent, and the best he has seen at 3 to 4 percent unless the offer is extraordinary.
Against that, he says a single email carrying a game to that same group’s roughly 10,000-member database drove about three times as many redemptions as the mailer, and that a local 7 Brew operator group ran one that did ten times better than a mailer they had recently sent. His framing of why is the part worth sitting with: the marginal cost of the digital version is zero, and the mailer leaves you with nothing afterward.
Even if I go in and I use the Smoothie King coupon that I got, Smoothie King has no idea who I am. The operator doesn’t know me. They don’t have my email address. There’s no way to contact me.
Vaidhy Murti, Founder and CEO, WIT
He is not asking for new budget. He is asking operators to move the local store marketing money they already spend on print into something that leaves a list behind. For a new-market opening — he cited a Swig launch — the mailer announcing the store becomes a slot machine campaign, and the people who show up on day one are now people the operator can reach again.
What does a campaign look like when it works?
The 7 Brew example is the one that will stick with most operators. They ran Flavor Madness last year and Brew Madness this year, through the month of March, with a scratch-and-win played in the drive-thru line while the order is being made. Prizes ran from free drinks to branded basketballs, Pop-A-Shots and jerseys. The grand prize was a Ford Bronco.
The mechanic that made it work was daily entry: play every day in March, and every play was another entry for the Bronco. Murti says last year’s winner was a 7 Brew regular who teaches special education, and the brand built a video around handing her the keys. That is the whole thesis in one story — a prize that money alone cannot buy, aligned to what the brand says it is about.
The Ziggi’s Coffee number is the cleanest financial proof point he offered. They emailed a lucky slot machine to their whole database for St. Patrick’s Day, redeemable same day. Murti says sales were up 15 percent against a comparable Tuesday. I had actually heard Ziggi’s CMO describe that uplift from the stage at FS Tech in Dallas a week before we recorded, without naming the vendor — so I can tell you the operator side of that story checks out.
How do you get to a third visit when you are not a coffee brand?
Through progressive profiling. Every time a guest plays another game, WIT asks one new question — which day part they usually visit, what kind of offer they actually want, how often they come in, whether they are already a rewards member. Each answer is one more filter the operator can segment on later.
That is what lets an operator stop sending everybody the same BOGO. Daily guests do not need an offer that cannibalizes a check they were going to write anyway. The guests who have come in once in two months are the ones worth spending margin on. Murti’s point is that the segmentation has to be earned question by question, not assumed.
Lize Monametsi made a related argument about forecasting in AI Forecasting’s Decision Gap — Lize Monametsi, Predictive Insights: the data is rarely the constraint, the decision you take from it is.
How do you keep the giveaways from eating your margin?
By pricing each prize before you award it. Murti says WIT tracks the redemption rate of every prize type, then combines it with POS data to get the attachment rate and ticket size behind each one. That produces what he calls an expected revenue per code awarded, and the prize distribution is built from that number.
We can structure prizes in a way where the hit to your margin is fully capped, because we know it’s actually not even a hit — we know what the attachment rate is and what the average ticket size is.
Vaidhy Murti, Founder and CEO, WIT
He also makes the point that offers do not travel. A 9.99 dozen-donut offer that performed extremely well for one Dunkin’ group landed flat in a different market, where a free medium beverage was the winner. Which is an argument for running the test rather than copying the deck.
Does this replace the loyalty program?
No, and Murti was firm about it. WIT integrates with loyalty rather than competing with it, and one of the explicit goals is to push players into the rewards program. He says that for the Dunkin’ operators they work with, a guest who opts into Dunkin’ Rewards is worth about 70 percent more in lifetime value than one who does not — which is exactly why corporate keeps pushing the platform, and exactly why top-of-funnel acquisition is the valuable job.
Mechanically it is a checkbox. With 7 Brew, where loyalty is keyed to phone number, playing the game and ticking the box creates the loyalty account on the spot. If you are running Punchh or Paytronix or Thanx, none of that gets ripped out.
What surprised him in the data?
One progressive profiling question asked a Dunkin’ group’s guests why they chose Dunkin’ over the 7 Brew across the street, Starbucks or the local shop. Friendly staff came back third — ahead of convenience, ahead of speed of service, ahead of selection.
I never would have guessed that this is the third most important reason that people are picking Dunkin’. They’re actually forming genuine connections with the staff at the operator level.
Vaidhy Murti, Founder and CEO, WIT
I told him about the CEO group I am part of that meets at Capital Grille rather than Fleming’s, every month, on an eight-hundred-dollar check, for no reason other than that one of them makes us feel like somebody and the other does not. We are in the hospitality business. It should not surprise us that hospitality shows up third in a regression. It surprises us anyway, which is the problem.
What does getting started look like?
Murti says WIT starts by understanding the goal — new openings, same-store sales, specific units missing their AUV target — then runs a low-cost pilot. Activations can be set up in under 10 minutes, there is no app for the guest to download and nothing new for the store to operate; the only in-store requirement is getting a QR code in front of people. He also offered a guarantee I will let him own: against a physical mailer, dollar for dollar, he says WIT will beat it on conversion or refund the test.
If you want the broader case for marketing you can actually measure, Brett Linkletter covered it in Restaurant Marketing You Can Track — Brett Linkletter, Dishio, and Pat Venn covered how guests are finding you in the first place in The Recommendation Economy Comes to Restaurants — Pat Venn, PRIMA. For the community-level version of the same instinct, Kyle Huck’s story in Why This Franchisee Gave Back $141K — Kyle Huck, Wings Etc. is worth your time.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage of restaurant transactions are anonymous?
Vaidhy Murti of WIT says the best QSR loyalty platforms capture 20 to 30 percent of total volume and most capture 10 to 15 percent, leaving roughly 70 percent of transactions untracked. At the individual franchisee level, where corporate owns the loyalty data, he describes guest identity as effectively 100 percent anonymous to the operator.
What redemption rate should a restaurant expect from a direct mailer?
Murti puts the QSR industry standard at 1 to 2 percent, with 3 to 4 percent being the best he has seen and only when the offer is unusually strong. One Dunkin’ group he works with mails 10,000 to 20,000 households and sees about 1 percent. He says a digital game sent to an owned email list pulled roughly three times those redemptions at effectively zero marginal cost.
Does gamification replace a restaurant loyalty program?
No. WIT integrates with existing loyalty platforms and uses the game as top-of-funnel acquisition, including an opt-in checkbox that creates the loyalty account during play. Murti says a Dunkin’ guest who opts into rewards is worth about 70 percent more in lifetime value, which is why converting anonymous players into members is the goal rather than running a parallel program.
How do you stop a prize giveaway from destroying margin?
By measuring the downstream behavior of each prize type. WIT tracks redemption rates per prize and combines them with POS attachment rates and ticket sizes to calculate an expected revenue per code awarded, then builds the prize distribution from that figure. Murti says this caps the margin exposure before a single code goes out.
How long does it take to launch a gamification campaign?
Murti says activations can be configured on the WIT platform in under 10 minutes, with WIT handling promotional graphics and execution end to end. There is no app for guests to download and no new system for store teams to learn — the operational requirement is getting a QR code in front of guests in the store, the drive-thru, the email list or on a delivery bag.
What I would do with this on Monday
- Find out what you spend on printed mailers in a year and what redemption rate you actually get. If you cannot answer the second half, that is the finding.
- Ask what percentage of your transactions you can attach to a named guest. Then ask the same question at the single-store level.
- Pick your next new-store opening as the test. It already has a marketing budget and no existing list to protect.
- Before you run anything, decide what you want to learn about your guests, not just what you want to give away. The question you ask is the asset.
- Check whether your prize mix has an expected revenue per code behind it, or whether you are guessing.
Want every word? The complete conversation is on the full transcript of RTG Ep. 365 with Vaidhy Murti.
You can reach WIT at witcontests.com/rtg.
Thanks to our sponsors. Restaurant Technologies keeps cooking oil management off your team’s plate and out of the back lot. And Yelp for Restaurants helps operators turn discovery into covers.
